Hi Chris
I think we've had this conversation...
In any case I'll share. In our site (Government Dept LMS only for staff) we have only ever allowed authenticated users to the site (no guest access at all).
At a course page level we also removed the 'Are you sure you want to enrol' screen/process.
When a staff member visits a page they are silently 'enroled' in it.
Also: we removed any form of module level guest access after our site crashed when many staff accessed a SCORM module as 'guests' (an allowable option in that module) at the same time.
The argument for silent enrolment is:
- In the early stages of your LMS users will find the 'Are you want to enrol' a barrier to actually commencing the course - this noticibly impacted our early adoption rates.
- As your catalogue of courses grows staff need more information about the course than can be contained in the Course Summary. Leading to high enrolment numbers but low completation ratios.
- It's a heavy administrative burden on every course page to configure what can and can't be accessed by Guests.
- If your course page isn't a 'course' (say, it's an information resource) the action of 'enroling' is inconsistent with the staff member's expectation of what they are getting and either forms a barrier to entry or creates an expectation that there is more than actually offered.
- In an Academic sense 'enrol' has a formal & defined meaning and both student & teacher understand what is does and doesn't mean. In business use, accessing the course page is generally less formal and when permission is required (ie to attend the sessions / pay the course fees) this can't be determined through the 'Are you sure you want to enrol' process.
- Our reporting is now enhanced by using the enrolment numbers as a valid 'level of interest' measurement.
- Course 'start' is measured by participation in assessment/F2F booking.
- We still control access to some courses by:
- Manual enrolment (close off self enrolment)
- One-time enrolment password
- Enrolment in one course (or role) triggers enrolment in another course.
Cheers
Austen